34.1 F
Friday, January 22, 2021

Kansas Supreme Court: The State Constitution Protects Abortion Rights

Sports Headlines

Competitive Basketball Games Mark Area Tournament Action Thursday

Top two seeds in the Twin Valley League girls basketball tournament fell Thursday night in the semifinals, as fourth seed Frankfort handed top seed...

Twin Valley League Tournament Update – 1/21/2021

BOYS BRACKET | GIRLS BRACKET GIRLS SCORES - 1/21 Frankfort 37, Valley Heights 34 Hanover 46, Doniphan West 45 Frankfort will face Hanover at 4 PM Saturday for...

Sporting KC signs Grayson Barber, Ozzie Cisneros and Brooks Thompson as Homegrown Players

(Jan. 20, 2021) -- Sporting Kansas City announced today that the club has signed 20-year-old midfielder Grayson Barber, 16-year-old forward Ozzie Cisneros and 18-year-old...

Big 12 Announces Kansas Men’s Basketball Schedule Changes

Courtesy of Kansas Athletics LAWRENCE, Kan. – The Big 12 Conference has announced two date changes for Kansas men’s basketball. The TCU at Kansas game...

Twin Valley League Boys Tournament Bracket Changed Due To COVID-19

BOYS BRACKET (UPDATED) | GIRLS BRACKET ONAGA, KAN. - The 2021 edition of the Twin Valley League basketball tournament is underway this week at both...
Derek Nester
Derek Nester was born and raised in Blue Rapids, and graduated from Valley Heights High School in May of 2000. He attended Cowley College in Arkansas City and Johnson County Community College in Overland Park studying Journalism & Media Communications.After stops at KFRM and KCLY radio in Clay Center, he joined KNDY in 2002 as a board operator and play by play announcer. Derek is now responsible for the digital content of Dierking Communications, Inc. six radio stations.In 2005 Derek joined the staff of KCFX radio in Kansas City as a production coordinator for the Kansas City Chiefs Radio Network, which airs on over 94 radio stations across 12 Midwest states and growing. In 2018 he became the Studio Coordinator at the Cumulus Kansas City broadcast center for Kansas City Chiefs Football.

By Dan Margolies & Celia Llopis-Jepsen – Kansas News Service

Kansas women have a fundamental right to abortion, the state’s Supreme Court ruled Friday — a decision that quickly had conservatives vowing to amend the state constitution.

The landmark ruling — triggered by a state ban on the most common form of second-trimester abortions — can’t be appealed.

Because it hinges on the state’s constitution, the ruling means abortion will remain legal in Kansas even if the U.S. Supreme Court someday reverses the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision that legalized abortion nationwide.

Friday’s 87-page decision will turbo-charge efforts among conservatives in the Kansas Legislature to ban abortion in the state constitution. That amendment would require support from two-thirds majorities in the House and Senate, followed by an OK from the state’s voters.

House speaker Ron Ryckman said the court flouted the “moral beliefs our state was founded upon.”

“Not responding would jeopardize decades of progress in Kansas law that has successfully reduced the number of abortions,” he said. “We will be working to put the question before the people.”

Senate President Susan Wagle, a Wichita Republican, criticized the decision and called abortion “violent.”

“Life is sacred,” she said, “beginning at conception.”

Lawmakers return to Topeka next week but have little time before the end of the session.

A one-line news release from Gov. Laura Kelly said she is “pleased” the ruling “conclusively respects and recognizes” women’s rights to make their own medical decisions.

The 6-1 decision cites the first section of the Kansas Constitution’s Bill of Rights: “All men are possessed of equal and inalienable natural rights, among which are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”

“We are now asked,” the justices wrote, “‘Is this declaration of rights more than an idealized aspiration? And, if so, do the substantive rights include a woman’s right to make decisions about her body, including the decision whether to continue her pregnancy? We answer these questions, ‘Yes.’”

That means, the court said, that a woman may “make her own decisions regarding her body, health, family formation, and family life — decisions that can include whether to continue a pregnancy.” The state can only curb that right if it shows “a compelling interest,” the justices wrote.

Genevieve Scott is a lawyer at the Center for Reproductive Rights, the main counsel for the plaintiffs who sued Kansas over a 2015 ban on certain abortions. The ruling, she said, will make it difficult for future laws against abortion to hold up in Kansas courts.

“Courts are going to be looking at it incredibly closely,” she said, “to make sure the state has met what is now an incredibly high bar.”

National Right to Life issued a statement calling the ruling “unconscionable” for allowing “unborn babies to be killed in such a gruesome manner.”

The question of whether Kansans have a constitutional right to abortion arose after two Overland Park physicians — Herbert Hodes and his daughter, Traci Nauser — challenged the ban on dilation and evacuation abortions.

The 2015 Kansas Unborn Child Protection from Dismemberment Abortion Act prohibited dilation and evacuation abortions. The only exceptions were saving the life of the mother, preventing impairment of major bodily functions of the mother, or where the fetus is already dead.

Kansas was the first in the nation to ban the procedure, used for nearly all second-trimester abortions. It accounts for 9% of the state’s abortions.

In today’s ruling, the Supreme Court upheld a trial court’s decision. That trial court had blocked the law, meaning physicians could still perform the procedure. The issue now returns to that lower court, where the Kansas Supreme Court’s decision means it’s highly likely that a fresh ruling will again protect the abortion procedure.

Scott, at the Center for Reproductive rights, said she is “fully confident” that will happen.

Justice Caleb Stegall wrote an 84-page dissent, arguing that Section 1 of the Constitution only prevents the state from passing laws that aren’t reasonably related to the common welfare or that are arbitrary, irrational or discriminatory.

Stegall said the majority’s decision “fundamentally alters the structure of our government to magnify the power of the state — all while using that power to arbitrarily grant a regulatory reprieve to the judicially privileged act of abortion.”

His dissent said the decision “abandons” the original meaning of that part of the Bill of Rights and “paints the interest in unborn life championed by millions of Kansans as rooted in an ugly prejudice.”

Justice Dan Biles agreed with the majority ruling but wrote separately that he would have used a different test to determine if the 2015 ban unduly restricted abortions.

Case history

The trial judge was Shawnee County District Judge Larry D. Hendricks. He blocked the law from taking effect, ruling that the Kansas Bill of Rights “independently protects the fundamental right to abortion.”

Hendricks ruled that alternatives to dilation and evacuation weren’t reasonable. He said the law “would force unwanted medical treatment on women, and in some instances would operate as a requirement that physicians experiment on women with known and unknown safety risks as a condition (of) accessing the fundamental right of abortion.”

Oral arguments took place at the Supreme Court in March 2017. The high court usually rules within months, not years. The amount of time it took to decide the case reflects the high stakes involved and the degree to which abortion has polarized Kansas politics.

Before the mid-1990s, Kansas had some of the least restrictive abortion laws in the country. Wichita was home to one of the nation’s few third-trimester abortion providers, physician George Tiller, who survived one attempt on his life and was later killed by an anti-abortion extremist in 2009.

In 1991, the Summer of Mercy anti-abortion protests spurred political mobilization that elected more anti-abortion lawmakers to the Kansas Legislature. They passed laws and regulations requiring minors to get consent from their parents for abortions, preventing state-funded insurance plans from covering abortions and requiring women on private insurance to pay for a separate abortion rider if they wanted insurance to cover it.

In January, Republican lawmakers proposed a constitutional amendment to effectively ban all abortions by declaring life begins at fertilization.

The bill lacked support from Kansas’ major anti-abortion group, Kansans for Life. KFL president Mary Kay Culp said she believed the amendment, if passed, would be struck down by the courts. Instead, she said the group would pursue its own amendment if the Supreme Court found a constitutional right to abortion.

Madeline Fox, a former Kansas News Service reporter, contributed to this article.

Dan Margolies is a senior reporter and editor at KCUR. You can reach him on Twitter @DanMargolies.

Celia Llopis-Jepsen is a reporter for the Kansas News Service, a collaboration of KCUR, Kansas Public Radio, KMUW and High Plains Public Radio covering health, education and politics. You can reach her on Twitter @Celia_LJ.

Kansas Headlines

Governor Laura Kelly Announces Kansas Moves to Phase 2 of COVID-19 Vaccine Distribution

Governor Laura Kelly will announce tomorrow the statewide move to Phase 2 of Kansas’ COVID-19 vaccination plan. With this move, all those aged 65+,...

KBI Update Regarding Suspicious Death Investigation In Crawford County

CRAWFORD COUNTY – The Kansas Bureau of Investigation (KBI) and the Crawford County Sheriff’s Office provided an update on the suspicious death investigation that...

State Conservation Commission Meeting February 1

MANHATTAN, Kansas — The State Conservation Commission will hold its regular meeting on Monday, February 1, 2021, at 10:00 a.m. using a virtual attendance...

KDA Offers Food Safety Webinar Series in 2021

MANHATTAN, Kansas — The Kansas Department of Agriculture’s food safety and lodging program will offer monthly online webinars on food safety issues beginning Monday,...

Governor Laura Kelly Appoints Christopher Etzel to Fill District Court Vacancy in the 2nd Judicial District

TOPEKA – Today Governor Laura Kelly appointed Christopher Etzel, Havensville, to the 2nd Judicial District vacancy created by the retirement of Chief...

Kansas News Service

Kansas Hospitals Seek Help From Nearby States, But The Whole Midwest Faces A COVID Surge

By Celia Llopis-Jepsen - Kansas News Service Hospitals in Colorado and Nebraska are calling Kansas in desperate search of beds for coronavirus patients. But Kansas...

Kansas Republicans Keep Their 3 Congressional Seats; Davids Reelected In Kansas City Suburbs

By Stephan Bisaha Stephen Koranda, Nadya Faulx, Aviva Okeson-Haberman - Kansas News Service Democrats and Republicans in Kansas will keep their seats in the U.S....

Republicans Keep Kansas’ Open Senate Seat By Electing Roger Marshall

By Jim McLean - Kansas News Service OVERLAND PARK, Kansas — Kansas Republican U.S. Rep. Roger Marshall is moving up to the U.S. Senate after...

‘It Is Not Sustainable’: Kansas’ Online Teachers Are Overworked And Quitting

WICHITA, Kansas — Less than a week into the new school year, the warning came: the school district’s COVID-19 learning plan expected too much from...

Kansas Nursing Homes Still Waiting On Coronavirus Testing Gear From The Feds, And Can’t Afford Labs

By Celia Llopis-Jepsen - Kansas News Service Phillips County Retirement Center got a coronavirus testing machine this month from the U.S. Department of Health and...