Olathe mom who was ejected from a school board meeting loses first round of her free speech lawsuit

By Dan Margolies – Kansas News Service

An Olathe woman who lost her race for Olathe school board and was later removed from a board meeting has lost her bid to prevent the board from enforcing its new policy governing public comments at meetings.

Jennifer Gilmore sued the board and various individuals in January, claiming they violated her First Amendment free-speech rights and the Kansas Open Meetings Act.

Gilmore, who has a child in the school district, ran for a seat on the school board in 2021, campaigning against mask mandates and critical race theory. She lost to Julie Steele by 65 votes.

At a Jan. 13, 2022, board meeting at which Steele and two other newly elected board members were sworn in, Gilmore got up to speak during the public comment portion.

After Gilmore made an apparent reference to Steele and her father’s expenditures on behalf of her campaign — and called Steele’s father, Johnson County precinct committeeman Jim Randall, a liar — the president of the board, Joe Beveridge, said, “You’re done. You are done.”

After a few more seconds of heated exchange, Beveridge called for a five-minute break, during which a school security employee and an assistant superintendent escorted her to Gilmore’s chair to collect her things and told her to leave the building.

At the time, the school board had a policy, since revised, allowing the school board president to interrupt statements that were disruptive or “not germane to the business activities of the Board.”

Gilmore’s comments came against the backdrop of increasingly acrimonious school board meetings across the country at which parents have badgered and even threatened school board members over COVID and other policies they disagree with.

Gilmore’s lawsuit originally challenged the Olathe school board’s old policy, but after it was revised in April, she amended it to challenge the new policy as well. The new policy deleted a provision that the school board president could deny speaking privileges to anyone making “personal attacks, or rude or defamatory remarks” about school district employees or students.

Gilmore nonetheless claimed she was unsure what she could say under the new policy and asked the court to issue a preliminary injunction barring it from taking effect.

On Friday, U.S. District Judge Holly L. Teeter denied Gilmore’s motion, finding that Gilmore was unlikely to prevail if the case were to go to trial. Teeter said the revised policy limiting public comments to topics “germane to the business of the Board” was a reasonable and viewpoint-neutral limitation that does not violate the First Amendment.

She also rejected Gilmore’s argument that the words “germane to the business of the Board” are unconstitutionally vague.

“People of ordinary intelligence would understand ‘germane’ in this context to mean relevant,” Teeter wrote. “The Court struggles to see how a person of ordinary intelligence would not understand that their remarks during a school board meeting should be relevant to the business of the school board.”

Gilmore was represented in her lawsuit by Linus Baker, a Stilwell lawyer who has filed a stream of mostly unsuccessful lawsuits challenging school vaccination and masking policies on religious grounds.

Reached on Monday, Baker said Teeter’s ruling only applied to the new policy and that “it doesn’t speak to what happens to Ms. Gilmore under the old policy.”

Baker said Gilmore was seeking nominal damages and attorney’s fees under the old policy and noted that the lawsuit “did in my mind motivate them to change their unconstitutional policy and get it revised.”

“So that was something that was accomplished in that regard,” Baker said. “And Judge Teeter has not spoken to the issue yet of not just what you can about under either policy but this idea that they had the ability to eject a speaker from the public meeting itself or the building.”

Michael Norris, a Leawood attorney who represented the school board, said he was “certainly pleased” with the court’s decision.

“We believe it was the correct outcome,” he said.

Hot this week

Kansas High School Football Playoff Scores – 11/13/2026

Kansas high school football playoff results span seven classifications. Notable winners included Otis-Bison, Axtell, Clifton-Clyde, Centralia, Silver Lake, Andale, and Bishop Miege. The semifinals are scheduled for November 20, featuring matchups such as Otis-Bison-Tescott, Hanover-Axtell, Clifton-Clyde-Oswego, Centralia-Rossville, Caney Valley-Silver Lake, Holcomb-Andale, and Tonganoxie-Bishop Miege.

🎙️ Valley Heights High School’s “The Mustang Minute” – 11/12/2026

Tune into the Valley Heights High School's "The Mustang...

🎙️ K-State Agriculture Today: 2309 – Grain Market Impacts from WASDE Report…Kansas Commodity Market

USDA Report Impact and Corn and Grain Sorghum Conversation Discussing...

🎙️ Public Affairs: Shelby Temps – Blue River Rail Trail Grant – 11/14/2026

Katy Jeter with KNDY Radio recently visited with Shelby...

Latest Headlines

🎙️ Frankfort High School’s “The Wildcat Wind Down” – 11/17/2026

Tune into the Frankfort High School's "The Wildcat Wind Down"...

Kansas Volleyball Association Unveils Official 2026 All-State Teams and Award Winners

The Kansas Volleyball Association announced its 2026 All-State volleyball teams, honoring outstanding players and coaches from Class 6A through 1A Division 2. Players and Coaches of the Year include Riley Riggs and Jessica Horstick in 6A, with top first-team athletes recognized statewide. Complete second-team and honorable mention lists are available online.

Mid-Continent League Announces 2026 All-League 11-Man Football Selections

The Mid-Continent League announced its 2026 11-man football honors, recognizing players from six schools across First Team, Second Team and Honorable Mention selections. Thomas More Prep and Smith Center led First Team representation. Five honors were unanimous, including Austin Liles, Jacob Seib, Owen Brewster and Dominick Kattenberg, highlighting outstanding performances throughout the season.

Kansas City Current Punches Ticket to NWSL Championship with Last-Minute Goal

Kansas City Current defeated Gotham FC 2-1 in a dramatic NWSL semifinal, advancing to the championship for the second time and first since 2022. Croix Bethune opened the scoring with a free kick before Haley Hopkins’ 89th-minute volley secured victory. The Current will face Washington Spirit on November 21 at Audi Field.

Chiefs Defeat Falcons, 35-13, as Patrick Mahomes Throws Five Touchdowns

The Kansas City Chiefs defeated the Atlanta Falcons 35-13, improving to 7-2 and sharing the AFC West lead. Patrick Mahomes threw for 348 yards and five touchdowns, while rookie Emmett Johnson excelled with 171 scrimmage yards and two scores. Kansas City’s defense also dominated, limiting Atlanta’s offense and key rusher Bijan Robinson.
- Advertisement -

Related Articles

Popular Categories

- Advertisement -